Skip to content
Free Shipping Over $70
Country/region
Antigua & Barbuda (XCD $)
Argentina (USD $)
Aruba (AWG ƒ)
Australia (AUD $)
Austria (EUR €)
Bahamas (BSD $)
Barbados (BBD $)
Belgium (EUR €)
Belize (BZD $)
Bermuda (USD $)
Bolivia (BOB Bs.)
Brazil (USD $)
British Indian Ocean Territory (USD $)
British Virgin Islands (USD $)
Canada (CAD $)
Cayman Islands (KYD $)
Chile (USD $)
Christmas Island (AUD $)
Colombia (USD $)
Cook Islands (NZD $)
Costa Rica (CRC ₡)
Curaçao (ANG ƒ)
Cyprus (EUR €)
Denmark (DKK kr.)
Dominican Republic (DOP $)
Ecuador (USD $)
El Salvador (USD $)
Falkland Islands (FKP £)
Faroe Islands (DKK kr.)
Fiji (FJD $)
Finland (EUR €)
France (EUR €)
Germany (EUR €)
Greece (EUR €)
Greenland (DKK kr.)
Grenada (XCD $)
Guatemala (GTQ Q)
Iceland (ISK kr)
Ireland (EUR €)
Italy (EUR €)
Jamaica (JMD $)
Luxembourg (EUR €)
Macao SAR (MOP P)
Maldives (MVR MVR)
Malta (EUR €)
Mexico (USD $)
Netherlands (EUR €)
New Zealand (NZD $)
Nicaragua (NIO C$)
Norfolk Island (AUD $)
North Macedonia (MKD ден)
Norway (USD $)
Panama (USD $)
Paraguay (PYG ₲)
Peru (PEN S/)
Pitcairn Islands (NZD $)
Poland (PLN zł)
Portugal (EUR €)
Qatar (QAR ر.ق)
Russia (USD $)
San Marino (EUR €)
Saudi Arabia (SAR ر.س)
Spain (EUR €)
St. Lucia (XCD $)
St. Martin (EUR €)
St. Pierre & Miquelon (EUR €)
St. Vincent & Grenadines (XCD $)
Svalbard & Jan Mayen (USD $)
Sweden (SEK kr)
Switzerland (CHF CHF)
Turks & Caicos Islands (USD $)
U.S. Outlying Islands (USD $)
United Arab Emirates (AED د.إ)
United Kingdom (GBP £)
United States (USD $)
Vatican City (EUR €)
Wallis & Futuna (XPF Fr)
Yemen (YER ﷼)
Update country/region
Country/region
United States (USD $)
Antigua & Barbuda
(XCD $)
Argentina
(USD $)
Aruba
(AWG ƒ)
Australia
(AUD $)
Austria
(EUR €)
Bahamas
(BSD $)
Barbados
(BBD $)
Belgium
(EUR €)
Belize
(BZD $)
Bermuda
(USD $)
Bolivia
(BOB Bs.)
Brazil
(USD $)
British Indian Ocean Territory
(USD $)
British Virgin Islands
(USD $)
Canada
(CAD $)
Cayman Islands
(KYD $)
Chile
(USD $)
Christmas Island
(AUD $)
Colombia
(USD $)
Cook Islands
(NZD $)
Costa Rica
(CRC ₡)
Curaçao
(ANG ƒ)
Cyprus
(EUR €)
Denmark
(DKK kr.)
Dominican Republic
(DOP $)
Ecuador
(USD $)
El Salvador
(USD $)
Falkland Islands
(FKP £)
Faroe Islands
(DKK kr.)
Fiji
(FJD $)
Finland
(EUR €)
France
(EUR €)
Germany
(EUR €)
Greece
(EUR €)
Greenland
(DKK kr.)
Grenada
(XCD $)
Guatemala
(GTQ Q)
Iceland
(ISK kr)
Ireland
(EUR €)
Italy
(EUR €)
Jamaica
(JMD $)
Luxembourg
(EUR €)
Macao SAR
(MOP P)
Maldives
(MVR MVR)
Malta
(EUR €)
Mexico
(USD $)
Netherlands
(EUR €)
New Zealand
(NZD $)
Nicaragua
(NIO C$)
Norfolk Island
(AUD $)
North Macedonia
(MKD ден)
Norway
(USD $)
Panama
(USD $)
Paraguay
(PYG ₲)
Peru
(PEN S/)
Pitcairn Islands
(NZD $)
Poland
(PLN zł)
Portugal
(EUR €)
Qatar
(QAR ر.ق)
Russia
(USD $)
San Marino
(EUR €)
Saudi Arabia
(SAR ر.س)
Spain
(EUR €)
St. Lucia
(XCD $)
St. Martin
(EUR €)
St. Pierre & Miquelon
(EUR €)
St. Vincent & Grenadines
(XCD $)
Svalbard & Jan Mayen
(USD $)
Sweden
(SEK kr)
Switzerland
(CHF CHF)
Turks & Caicos Islands
(USD $)
U.S. Outlying Islands
(USD $)
United Arab Emirates
(AED د.إ)
United Kingdom
(GBP £)
United States
(USD $)
Vatican City
(EUR €)
Wallis & Futuna
(XPF Fr)
Yemen
(YER ﷼)
Facebook
Bluesky
Instagram
YouTube
Home
Shop the Goods
Shop the Goods
Shop All of Our Goods
Gift Sets & Bundles
Hot Sauce
Fat Toad Farm Goat's Milk Caramel
Maple Sweetened Baked Goods
Whole Seed Mustards
Salsas & Sauces
Heady Topper Collection
As Seen On Hot Ones Collection
Award Winning Collection
Guster Collection
Merch
The Pantry
Collaborations
Collaborations
Genersaucity Charities
Small Farm & Business Collaborations
Recipes
Recipes
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Recipes & Pairings
Fat Toad Farm Carmel Recipes & Pairings
Services & Wholesale
Services & Wholesale
Wholesale Purchasing
White Label
Custom Copacking
Corporate Gifts
Wedding Favors
About Us
About Us
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont's Story
Fat Toad Farm's Story
In the News
For the Media
Customer Reviews
Retired Hot Sauces
The Toad & The Butterfly - a Blog
Contact
Contact
Visit, Call or Follow Us
Common Questions
Shipping & Pickup
Events We're Attending
Log In
Facebook
Bluesky
Instagram
YouTube
Country/region
United States (USD $)
Antigua & Barbuda
(XCD $)
Argentina
(USD $)
Aruba
(AWG ƒ)
Australia
(AUD $)
Austria
(EUR €)
Bahamas
(BSD $)
Barbados
(BBD $)
Belgium
(EUR €)
Belize
(BZD $)
Bermuda
(USD $)
Bolivia
(BOB Bs.)
Brazil
(USD $)
British Indian Ocean Territory
(USD $)
British Virgin Islands
(USD $)
Canada
(CAD $)
Cayman Islands
(KYD $)
Chile
(USD $)
Christmas Island
(AUD $)
Colombia
(USD $)
Cook Islands
(NZD $)
Costa Rica
(CRC ₡)
Curaçao
(ANG ƒ)
Cyprus
(EUR €)
Denmark
(DKK kr.)
Dominican Republic
(DOP $)
Ecuador
(USD $)
El Salvador
(USD $)
Falkland Islands
(FKP £)
Faroe Islands
(DKK kr.)
Fiji
(FJD $)
Finland
(EUR €)
France
(EUR €)
Germany
(EUR €)
Greece
(EUR €)
Greenland
(DKK kr.)
Grenada
(XCD $)
Guatemala
(GTQ Q)
Iceland
(ISK kr)
Ireland
(EUR €)
Italy
(EUR €)
Jamaica
(JMD $)
Luxembourg
(EUR €)
Macao SAR
(MOP P)
Maldives
(MVR MVR)
Malta
(EUR €)
Mexico
(USD $)
Netherlands
(EUR €)
New Zealand
(NZD $)
Nicaragua
(NIO C$)
Norfolk Island
(AUD $)
North Macedonia
(MKD ден)
Norway
(USD $)
Panama
(USD $)
Paraguay
(PYG ₲)
Peru
(PEN S/)
Pitcairn Islands
(NZD $)
Poland
(PLN zł)
Portugal
(EUR €)
Qatar
(QAR ر.ق)
Russia
(USD $)
San Marino
(EUR €)
Saudi Arabia
(SAR ر.س)
Spain
(EUR €)
St. Lucia
(XCD $)
St. Martin
(EUR €)
St. Pierre & Miquelon
(EUR €)
St. Vincent & Grenadines
(XCD $)
Svalbard & Jan Mayen
(USD $)
Sweden
(SEK kr)
Switzerland
(CHF CHF)
Turks & Caicos Islands
(USD $)
U.S. Outlying Islands
(USD $)
United Arab Emirates
(AED د.إ)
United Kingdom
(GBP £)
United States
(USD $)
Vatican City
(EUR €)
Wallis & Futuna
(XPF Fr)
Yemen
(YER ﷼)
Log in
Search
Search
Log in
0
0 items
Subtotal
$ 0.00
Home
Shop the Goods
Shop All of Our Goods
Gift Sets & Bundles
Hot Sauce
Fat Toad Farm Goat's Milk Caramel
Maple Sweetened Baked Goods
Whole Seed Mustards
Salsas & Sauces
Heady Topper Collection
As Seen On Hot Ones Collection
Award Winning Collection
Guster Collection
Merch
The Pantry
Collaborations
Genersaucity Charities
Small Farm & Business Collaborations
Recipes
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Recipes & Pairings
Fat Toad Farm Carmel Recipes & Pairings
Services & Wholesale
Wholesale Purchasing
White Label
Custom Copacking
Corporate Gifts
Wedding Favors
About Us
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont's Story
Fat Toad Farm's Story
In the News
For the Media
Customer Reviews
Retired Hot Sauces
The Toad & The Butterfly - a Blog
Contact
Visit, Call or Follow Us
Common Questions
Shipping & Pickup
Events We're Attending
Log In
Fat Toad Farm Traditional Goat's Milk Caramel
Recipes & Pairings
Snacks & Sweets
Coffee Caramel Cayenne Brownies
Sunday Brunch Crepes With Caramel Sauce
Welcome Summer Madeleines
Miss Cheesemonger Pairings
Spicy Dark Chocolate Caramel Churros
Caramel Apple Tart
Caramel Coffee Rolls
Homemade Snickers Bars
Caramel Affogatos
Caramel Baked Apples
The Vermont S'more
Caramel Whoopie Pies
Caramel Popcorn
Caramel S'mores
Apple Hand Pies With Caramel Dipping Sauce
Apple Brie Prosciutto Caramel Panini
Chocolate Walnut Bread Pudding w/ Caramel Sauce
Cheese Cone With Caramel
Salted Bourbon Caramel Almonds
Caramel Baked Brie
Drinks
Goat's Milk Caramel Latte
Goat's Milk Caramel Eggnog
Salted Bourbon Caramel Hot Chocolate
Homemade Caramel Irish Cream
Cajeta & Guinness
Spiced Caramel Chai
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Recipes & Pairings
Recently Viewed
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Shopping Cart
Spend
[remain]
more to receive
Free Shipping
!
Congratulations!
You've got
Free Shipping!
Free
Shipping
Please note*:
[product_count] product(s) in your cart excluded from the free shipping option.
Your cart is empty
Let's fill it with
YUM!
Check out our best selling collections!
Fat Toad Farm Goat's Milk Caramel
Hot Sauces
Gift Sets & Bundles
Award Winners & Best Sellers
Continue shopping
Have an account?
Log in
to check out faster.
Loading...
You may also like
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
