Gifts & Collections

When it comes to sharing the Butterfly Bakery of Vermont and Fat Toad Farm love with friends and family, we've got you covered with these specially curated collections and lovely gift baskets. Can't decide what to get? We've got gift cards too!

34 results
Hot Sauce of the Season - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Hot Sauce of the Season
$ 142.00 $ 160.00
in your cart
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Hot Ones Line Up
Hot Ones Trio
$ 32.50 $ 35.00
in your cart
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Taco Vibes Only and Mellow Vibes Only Hot Sauces
Taco Sauce Duo
$ 24.00 $ 25.00
in your cart
Gift Card - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Gift Card
From $ 10.00
Show options
Fat Toad Farm Sweet Quartet
Sweet Quartet Petit Caramel Sampler
$ 34.99
Show options
Fat Toad Farm Full Line of Goat's Milk Caramel Sauces
Flight of Petit Caramels
$ 50.00
in your cart
Fat Toad Farm Caramel Apple Kit
DIY Caramel Apple Kit
$ 23.49
in your cart
Fat Toad Farm Sweet Duo Original & Salted Bourbon
Sweet Duo Caramel Gift Box
$ 34.99
Show options
Ultimate Farm-to-Fork Set
$ 80.00 $ 83.98
in your cart
Grilling Bundle
$ 36.00 $ 40.00
in your cart
Mustard Lovers Bundle
$ 45.00 $ 50.00
in your cart
Beer Lovers Bundle
$ 36.00 $ 40.00
in your cart
Ultimate Heady Gift Basket - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Ultimate Heady Gift Basket
$ 60.00
in your cart
Teetotaler Hot Sauce Set - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Teetotaler Hot Sauce Set
$ 35.50 $ 40.00
in your cart
Savory Sensation - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Savory Sensation
$ 76.00 $ 80.00
in your cart
Super-Hot Hot Sauce Collection
$ 42.00 $ 45.00
in your cart
Box O' Granola Set - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Box O' Granola Set
$ 34.00 $ 37.87
in your cart
Sweet and Savory Gift Set - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Sweet and Savory Gift Set
$ 61.00 $ 64.28
in your cart
Fat Toad Farm Full Line of Goat's Milk Caramel Sauces
The Top Flight
$ 120.00
in your cart
Fat Toad Farm Caramel Drinking Chocolate Kit
Drinking Chocolate Kit
$ 28.19
in your cart
Fat Toad Farm Sweet Love Kit
Fat Toad Farm Sweet Love Kit
$ 29.89
in your cart
Toads and Wild Woods - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Toads and Wild Woods
$ 28.00
in your cart
Sweets Combo! Caramel And Taza Chocolate - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Sweets Combo! Caramel And Taza Chocolate
$ 20.00
in your cart
Go Green Hot Sauce Set - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Go Green Hot Sauce Set
$ 28.00 $ 30.00
in your cart
Three hot sauce bottles on a wooden surface with a gray background
Micro Dose August Bundle
$ 28.00 $ 30.00
in your cart
Micro Dose September Bundle
$ 28.00 $ 30.00
in your cart
Sweet Heat Gift Basket - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Sweet Heat Gift Basket
$ 70.00
in your cart
Mustard Lover's Gift Basket - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Mustard Lover's Gift Basket
$ 60.00
in your cart
Cookies and Caramel Gift Basket - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Cookies and Caramel Gift Basket
$ 49.00
in your cart
Parfait Partners Set - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Parfait Partners Set
$ 29.00 $ 32.06
in your cart
Cozy Tea Set - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Cozy Tea Set
$ 36.00 $ 39.98
in your cart
Sriracha Essentials Set - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Sriracha Essentials Set
$ 25.75 $ 28.00
in your cart
Charcuterie Complements Set - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Charcuterie Complements Set
$ 33.00 $ 36.99
in your cart
Barrel Aged Cold Brewed Vanilla Extract - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Barrel Aged Cold Brewed Vanilla Extract
$ 20.00
in your cart