Products

104 results
Photo of a 2oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Mulled Cider caramel against a white background.
*NEW FLAVOR* Mulled Cider Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Photo of a bottle of Barrel Aged Artesano Vinegar from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone countertop with a rustic wood background.
Barrel Aged Artesano Vinegar
From $ 6.00
Show options
Photo of a bottle of Cold Brewed Barrel Aged vanilla extract from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone surface.
Barrel Aged Cold Brewed Vanilla Extract
$ 20.00
in your cart
Photo of a light blue utility key chain with the white Butterfly Bakery of Vermont logo on it and its knife, nail file, bottle opener, screwdriver and nail scissor tools on display.
BBVT Keychain Knife
$ 8.99
in your cart
Photo of black ceramic mug with a blue interior and the Butterfly Bakery of Vermont logo printed on the side, sitting on a smooth reflective surface with a white background.
BBVT Logo Mug
$ 15.99
in your cart
Photo of 3 bags of granola and 2 Chocolate Peanut Butter bars from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone countertop.
Box O' Granola Set
$ 34.00 $ 37.87
in your cart
Photo of a multi-colored tie-dyed t-shirt with the Butterfly Bakery of Vermont logo printed on it, laid out on a wood tabletop.
Butterfly Bakery T-Shirt
$ 27.00
Show options
Photo of a bottle of Carrot Coriander Ginger hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table.
Carrot Coriander Ginger Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Maple Wood Smoked Onion hot sauce and a jar of Heady Topper mustard from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, and a jar of Fat Toad Farm original caramel, positioned on a stone countertop.
Charcuterie Complements Set
$ 31.00 $ 34.99
in your cart
Photo of a wrapped Chocolate Peanut Butter bar from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside a peanuts in their shell and chocolate chunks.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar
$ 5.00
in your cart
Photo of a box of Chocolate Peppermint snaps from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside chocolate chunks and a few of the snaps.
Chocolate Peppermint Snap
$ 7.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Cilantro Onion hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table with 3 green jalapenos, an onion and some cilantro leaves.
Cilantro Onion Hot Sauce
From $ 5.00
Show options
Photo of a 2oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Cinnamon caramel against a white background.
Cinnamon Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Photo of 2 bottles of Clarified Tomato Broth from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a wood tabletop with a gray background.
Clarified Tomato Broth
$ 6.00
in your cart
Photo of a 2oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Cold Brew Coffee caramel from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont against a white background.
Cold Brew Coffee Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Photo of a bottle of Ooh La La hot sauce, a jar of Gustard mustard, a bag of Gusternola granola and a tin of Guster hot chocolate mix, all from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a wood tabletop.
Complete Guster Collection
$ 32.00 $ 35.78
in your cart
Photo of a 2 jars of Fat Toad Farm caramel and 2 boxes of Butterfly Bakery of Vermont cookie snaps nestled in a gift basket with wood shavings, positioned on a stone countertop and a rustic wood background.
Cookies and Caramel Gift Basket
$ 49.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Fat Toad Farm caramel, a box of Butterfly Bakery of Vermont maple spice snaps and a black mug, all placed on a stone countertop.
Cozy Tea Set
$ 36.00 $ 39.98
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Crushed Tomato sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone countertop with a rustic wood background.
Crushed Tomato Sauce
$ 10.00
in your cart
Photo of an 8oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Cinnamon caramel, 4 wood sticks for piercing apples, and a gift box with the FTF logo and "Caramel Apple Kit" on it.
DIY Caramel Apple Kit
$ 23.49
in your cart
Photo of two 2oz jars of Fat Toad Farm caramel, a disc of Taza Dark Chocolate Mexicano, and a gift box with the FTF logo and "Drinking Chocolate Kit" on it.
Drinking Chocolate Kit
$ 28.19
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Dutchess Mystery Pepper hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table.
Dutchess Mystery Pepper Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a box of Earl Grey & Orange snaps from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside orange slices, and tea bag and 4 of the snaps.
Earl Grey & Orange Snaps
$ 7.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Elderflower Ghost Craft Spirit hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone countertop.
Elderflower Ghost Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of two 2oz jars of Fat Toad Farm caramel, a cloth bag filled with heart-shaped chocolates, and a gift box with the FTF logo and "Sweet Love" on it.
Fat Toad Farm Sweet Love Kit
$ 29.89
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Fermented Jalapeno powder from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, with a white background.
Fermented Jalapeno Powder
$ 8.00
in your cart
Photo of 2oz jars of all 8 flavors of Fat Toad Farm caramel from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont.
Flight of Petit Caramels
$ 50.00
in your cart
Photo of Focal Habanero craft beer hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table.
Focal Habanero Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Garlic Lime Tomatillo salsa from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table.
Garlic Lime Tomatillo Salsa
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Ghost Verde Pickle hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside green jalapenos, orange habaneros, garlic scapes and a cucumber.
Ghost Verde Pickle Genersaucity Hot Sauce
From $ 9.00
Show options
Graphic image of a red gift card with a white ribbon and bow.
Gift Card
From $ 10.00
Show options
Photo of a bottle each of Heady Topper, Ghost Verde Pickle and Garlic Scape hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone countertop.
Go Green Hot Sauce Set
$ 25.00 $ 27.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Gustard mustard from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside a green jalapeno, a cucumber and a garlic scape.
Gustard - A Guster Mustard
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a bag of Gusternola granola from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table scattered with a handful of granola.
GusterNola - Miller Mix
From $ 9.29
Show options
Photo of a bottle of Habanero Heady hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, sitting on a stone countertop and a bleached wood background.
Habanero Heady Craft Beer Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Habanero Lime Switchback hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table with fresh limes and a bottle of Switchback Ale.
Habanero Lime Switchback Craft Beer Hot Sauce
From $ 5.00
Show options
104 results