Products

104 results
Photo of a wax-dipped bottle of Rum Barrel Fermented Smoked Jalapeno hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, sitting atop a rum barrel on its side.
Rum Barrel Fermented Smoked Jalapeno Hot Sauce
$ 14.00
in your cart
Photo of a 2oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Salted Bourbon caramel from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, with a white background.
Salted Bourbon Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Photo of 4 bottles of hot sauce and 4 jars of mustard from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone countertop.
Savory Sensation
$ 69.00 $ 72.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Garlic Scape sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table with garlic scapes wrapped abound the base of the bottle.
Scape Sauce
From $ 5.00
Show options
Photo of Smoked Eggplant Paprika hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table.
Smoked Eggplant Paprika Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Smoked Onion Salsa from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside an onion and cilantro leaves.
Smoked Onion Salsa
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a 2oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Spicy Dark Chocolate caramel against a white background.
Spicy Dark Chocolate Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Photo of a bottle of Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha hot sauce, and a jar each of Maple Sriracha mustard and Sriracha powder from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont.
Sriracha Essentials Set
$ 24.00 $ 26.00
in your cart
Photo of Strawberry Basil hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table.
Strawberry Basil Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of Super Hot Odds & Ends hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table.
Super Hot Odds and Ends Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle each of Red Ghost Reaper, Dutchess Mystery Pepper, Taco Vibes Only and Elderflower Ghost hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone countertop.
Super-Hot Hot Sauce Collection
$ 39.00 $ 41.00
in your cart
A bottle of Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha hot sauce, a jar of Hard Cider Smoked Onion mustard, a jar of Fat Toad Farm caramel, a bag of Mighty Tasty granola, a chocolate peanut butter bar, a bag of raspberry almond cookies and a box of Maple Ginger snaps, all from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont.
Sweet and Savory Gift Set
$ 59.00 $ 62.28
in your cart
Photo of two 8oz jars of Fat Toad Farm caramel and a gift box with the FTF logo and "Sweet Duo" on it.
Sweet Duo Caramel Gift Box
$ 34.99
Show options
Photo of 3 jars of Fat Toad Farm caramel and a bottle each of Maple Rum Chipotle and Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, all nestled in a gift basket with wood shavings, positioned on a stone countertop and a rustic wood background.
Sweet Heat Gift Basket
$ 69.00
in your cart
Photo of four 2oz jars of Fat Toad Farm caramel and a gift box with the FTF logo and "Sweet Quartet" on it.
Sweet Quartet Petit Caramel Sampler
$ 34.99
Show options
Photo of an 8oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Vanilla Bean caramel from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, alongside a disc of Taza Dark Chocolate Mexicano, against a white background.
Sweets Combo! Caramel And Taza Chocolate
$ 20.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Taco Vibes Only hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table, along with open face. soft shell tacos and scattered cilantro leaves.
Taco Vibes Only Hot Sauce
From $ 7.00
Show options
Photo of a bottle each of Maple Wood Smoked Onion, Vermont Habs, Cilantro Onion and Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone countertop.
Teetotaler Hot Sauce Set
$ 32.00 $ 36.00
in your cart
Photo of a 2oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Original caramel from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, with a white background.
The Original Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Photo of 8oz jars of all 8 flavors of Fat Toad Farm caramel from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont.
The Top Flight
$ 120.00
in your cart
Photo of an 8oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Original caramel from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, alongside a 6.8oz bottle of Wild Woods Vermont Maple Syrup.
Toads and Wild Woods
$ 28.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Tomatillo Chipotle salsa from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone surface with blurred trees and plants in the background.
Tomatillo Chipotle Salsa
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Tomatillo Corn hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone counter.
Sold Out
Tomatillo Corn Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
Photo of a bottle of Tomato Ginger Scotch Bonnet hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table.
Tomato Ginger Scotch Bonnet Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle each of Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Red Heady, Heady Topper and Habanero Heady hot sauce, along with a jar of Heady Topper mustard, all nestled in a gift basket with wood shavings, positioned on a stone countertop and a rustic wood background.
Ultimate Heady Gift Basket
$ 59.00
in your cart
Photo of a 2oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Vanilla Bean caramel from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont against a white background.
Vanilla Bean Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Photo of a bottle of Vermont Habs hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table with red jalapenos falling from above.
Vermont Habs Hot Sauce
From $ 5.00
Show options
Photo of a jar of Vermont Jalapeno mustard from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a wood table alongside green jalapenos and whole mustard seeds.
Vermont Jalapeno Mustard
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a 2oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Vermont Maple caramel from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont against a white background.
Vermont Maple Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Photo of copper round shaped bottle openers engraved with the Butterfly Bakery of Vermont logo.
1 in stock
Vintage Copper Bottle Opener
$ 3.99 $ 6.00
in your cart
Photo of Wax Pepper Kale Rosemary hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table.
Wax Pepper Kale Rosemary Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Wicked Ginger hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone countertop.
Sold Out
Wicked Ginger Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
104 results