The caramel that's captured so many spoons

The Original Caramel - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

 

Hey friends,

At Fat Toad Farm, we spend hours gently hand-stirring fresh Vermont goat’s milk until it transforms into something unforgettable: rich, creamy, small-batch caramel made the slow way, just like it’s been done for generations.

And here’s the thing: we’ve seen firsthand how one jar has a way of turning into a pantry staple.

If you haven’t had your moment with our Salted Bourbon, Vermont Maple, or Original Goat’s Milk Caramel lately, now’s the time to treat yourself - or surprise someone else with the kind of gift that doesn’t last long (because it’s too good not to eat).

Curious what all the fuss is about?

Take home a jar today and see why our caramel has been featured in The New York TimesThe Today Show, and countless happy kitchens across the country.

We’re proud to be a small Vermont team making something real, something slow, and something truly special. Thanks for supporting what we do - every jar tells that story.

With sticky elbows and full hearts,
Claire and the Fat Toad Farm Team




Fat Toad Farm Original Caramel Sauce
Having a hard time deciding what flavors to get?  Get this flight which includes a petit 2 oz jar of every one of our caramel flavors - Original, Vanilla Bean, Salted Bourbon, Cinnamon, Vermont Maple, Spicy Dark Chocolate, Cold Brew Coffee and Mulled Cider.  A wonderful present for one of your specials.  Packaged in a gift box.


Shop Now