Hot Sauce

View all
Photo of a wax-dipped bottle of Rum Barrel Fermented Smoked Jalapeno hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, sitting atop a rum barrel on its side.
Rum Barrel Fermented Smoked Jalapeno Hot Sauce
$ 14.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Maple Wood Smoked Onion hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table with 3 red jalapenos and an onion.
Maple Wood Smoked Onion Hot Sauce
From $ 5.00
Show options
Photo of a bottle of Taco Vibes Only hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table, along with open face. soft shell tacos and scattered cilantro leaves.
Taco Vibes Only Hot Sauce
From $ 7.00
Show options
Photo of a bottle of Heady Topper hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside 4 green jalapenos and 2 cans of Heady Topper beer in the background.
Heady Topper Hot Sauce
From $ 5.00
Show options
Photo of a bottle of Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table with 3 red jalapenos and a leaf shaped bottle of maple syrup.
Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha Hot Sauce
From $ 5.00
Show options

Fat Toad Farm Caramel

View all
Photo of a 2oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Original caramel from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, with a white background.
The Original Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Photo of a 2oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Mulled Cider caramel against a white background.
*NEW FLAVOR* Mulled Cider Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Photo of a 2oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Salted Bourbon caramel from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, with a white background.
Salted Bourbon Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Photo of a 2oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Vermont Maple caramel from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont against a white background.
Vermont Maple Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Photo of a 2oz jar of Fat Toad Farm Spicy Dark Chocolate caramel against a white background.
Spicy Dark Chocolate Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options

Maple Sweetened Baked Goods

View all
Photo of a bag of Mighty Tasty granola from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table scattered with a handful of granola.
Mighty Tasty Granola
From $ 5.00
Show options
Photo of a box of Maple Ginger snaps from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside fresh ginger root, a leaf-shaped bottle of maple syrup and a few of the snaps.
Maple Gingersnaps
$ 7.00
in your cart
Photo of a stack of Raspberry Almond cookies from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside fresh raspberries and almonds.
Raspberry Almond Cookies
$ 6.00
in your cart
Photo of a wrapped Chocolate Peanut Butter bar from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside a peanuts in their shell and chocolate chunks.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar
$ 5.00
in your cart
Photo of a box of Maple Spice snaps from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside cloves, a stick of cinnamon and 3 of the snaps.
Maple Spice Snaps
$ 7.00
in your cart

Mustard

View all
Photo of a jar of Gustard mustard from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside a green jalapeno, a cucumber and a garlic scape.
Gustard - A Guster Mustard
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Heady Topper mustard from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a wood table in front of 2 cans of Heady Topper beer and whole mustard seeds falling from above.
Heady Topper Mustard
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Hard Cider Smoked Onion mustard from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table along with an onion, 2 apples and 2 cans of hard cider.
Hard Cider Smoked Onion Mustard
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Maple Sriracha mustard from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a wood table alongside red jalapeno peppers, garlic scapes, and a maple leaf-shaped bottle of maple syrup.
Maple Sriracha Mustard
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Vermont Jalapeno mustard from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a wood table alongside green jalapenos and whole mustard seeds.
Vermont Jalapeno Mustard
$ 9.00
in your cart

Salsas & Sauces

View all
Photo of a jar of Smoked Onion Salsa from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside an onion and cilantro leaves.
Smoked Onion Salsa
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Garlic Lime Tomatillo salsa from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table.
Garlic Lime Tomatillo Salsa
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Tomatillo Chipotle salsa from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone surface with blurred trees and plants in the background.
Tomatillo Chipotle Salsa
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Crushed Tomato sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone countertop with a rustic wood background.
Crushed Tomato Sauce
$ 10.00
in your cart
Photo of 2 bottles of Clarified Tomato Broth from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a wood tabletop with a gray background.
Clarified Tomato Broth
$ 6.00
in your cart

Spices & Specials

View all
Photo of a jar of Maple Wood Smoked Chipotle powder from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, with a white background.
Maple Wood Smoked Chipotle Powder
$ 8.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Fermented Jalapeno powder from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, with a white background.
Fermented Jalapeno Powder
$ 8.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Maple Sriracha powder from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, with a white background.
Maple Sriracha Powder
$ 8.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Hot Sauce powder from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, with a solid white background.
Hot Sauce Powder
$ 8.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Cold Brewed Barrel Aged vanilla extract from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone surface.
Barrel Aged Cold Brewed Vanilla Extract
$ 20.00
in your cart

Guster Goods

View all
Photo of a bottle of Ooh La La hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table with a butternut squash and 3 red jalapenos.
Ooh La La Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a jar of Gustard mustard from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table alongside a green jalapeno, a cucumber and a garlic scape.
Gustard - A Guster Mustard
$ 9.00
in your cart
Photo of a bag of Gusternola granola from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a rustic wood table scattered with a handful of granola.
GusterNola - Miller Mix
From $ 9.29
Show options
Photo of a bottle of Ooh La La hot sauce, a jar of Gustard mustard, a bag of Gusternola granola and a tin of Guster hot chocolate mix, all from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a wood tabletop.
Complete Guster Collection
$ 32.00 $ 35.78
in your cart

Gifts & Collections

View all
Photo of a bottle each of Maple Wood Smoked Onion, Vermont Habs, Cilantro Onion and Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha hot sauce from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone countertop.
Teetotaler Hot Sauce Set
$ 32.00 $ 36.00
in your cart
Photo of 4 bottles of hot sauce and 4 jars of mustard from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone countertop.
Savory Sensation
$ 69.00 $ 72.00
in your cart
Photo of a bottle of Ooh La La hot sauce, a jar of Gustard mustard, a bag of Gusternola granola and a tin of Guster hot chocolate mix, all from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a wood tabletop.
Complete Guster Collection
$ 32.00 $ 35.78
in your cart
A bottle of Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha hot sauce, a jar of Hard Cider Smoked Onion mustard, a jar of Fat Toad Farm caramel, a bag of Mighty Tasty granola, a chocolate peanut butter bar, a bag of raspberry almond cookies and a box of Maple Ginger snaps, all from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont.
Sweet and Savory Gift Set
$ 59.00 $ 62.28
in your cart
Photo of 3 bags of granola and 2 Chocolate Peanut Butter bars from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont, positioned on a stone countertop.
Box O' Granola Set
$ 34.00 $ 37.87
in your cart
Why we do what we do