Small Batch Traditional Goat's Milk Caramel
Every jar of Fat Toad Farm Traditional Caramel is made by hand in small batches using a slow, traditional cooking process that creates rich, velvety flavor.
We partner with small Vermont farms that are chosen specifically for the mild, sweet goat’s milk they produce - the perfect foundation for our smooth and creamy caramel.
Whether poured over ice cream, paired with ripe fruit or fine cheese, or stirred into a morning latte, our caramel transforms everyday moments into something indulgent and unforgettable.
A Sweet Beginning - The Fat Toad Farm Story
Fat Toad Farm began in 2007 as a homesteading experiment with a single French Alpine doe named Jupiter. What started as a backyard project quickly grew into a beloved Vermont brand known for its rich, hand-stirred goat’s milk caramel sauces. Each batch is made using just a few fresh, all-natural ingredients and a traditional slow-cooking method that brings out deep, caramelized flavor.
Made with Milk from Vermont Farms
As the business grew, Fat Toad Farm transitioned from milking their own herd to working closely with local partners Ayers Brook Dairy and Joneslan Farm. These farms produce the mild, sweet goat’s milk that gives the caramel its smooth texture and signature flavor. It's a collaboration rooted in Vermont’s strong agricultural community and shared commitment to quality.
Continuing the Tradition
In 2022, Fat Toad Farm Caramel found its new home at Butterfly Bakery of Vermont in Barre. BBVT proudly continues the tradition of crafting caramel by hand in small batches, using the same time-honored techniques and simple ingredients. As part of BBVT’s award-winning farm-to-fork product line, Fat Toad Farm Caramel remains as rich, creamy, and true to its roots as ever.
Simple Ingredients, Endless Possibilities
Fat Toad Farm Caramel is a kitchen staple with countless uses. Drizzle it over ice cream, swirl it into coffee, pair it with fruit or especially cheese, or use it to elevate your favorite desserts. Or follow our lead, skip the extras and enjoy it right off the spoon.
Featured Product
Sweet Heat Gift Basket
$ 70.00
Looking for a gift that’s equal parts sweet and spicy? The Sweet Heat Gift Basket is here to please every palate. This delicious collection includes three jars of Fat Toad Farm’s rich, creamy traditional goat’s milk caramel and two of our hot sauces infused with just a touch of sweetness, offering an irresistible balance of savory and sweet.
Fat Toad Farm goat's milk caramel is a true treat, offering velvety richness and rich, complex flavors. It’s ideal for drizzling over desserts, mixing into coffee, or even pairing with cheese boards. The hot sauces, crafted with locally sourced ingredients, provide a tantalizing kick of heat softened by natural sweetness, adding depth to marinades, sandwiches, or even adventurous desserts.
It’s a gift that works for every occasion—ideal for those who enjoy sweetness as much as they love a touch of spice. Whether you’re shopping for a foodie, a spice lover, or someone who enjoys discovering unique flavor pairings, this gift basket is an excellent choice.
The Sweet Heat Gift Basket Includes:
- 2oz Original Fat Toad Farm caramel
- 2oz Vermont Maple Fat Toad Farm caramel
- 2oz Cinnamon Fat Toad Farm caramel
- Maple Rum Chipotle hot sauce
- Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha hot sauce