Fat Toad Farm Caramel

Since 2007, Fat Toad Farm has worked to perfect the art of goat's milk caramel making, focusing on traditional cooking methods and using a small number of fresh, simple, all-natural ingredients.


In 2022, founders, Steve, Judith and Calley were ready to move on and found a new home for Fat Toad Farm Caramel just 20 miles up the road at Butterfly Bakery of Vermont in Barre, Vermont where we continue to make slow processed, hand made caramel in the same traditional way.


Our goal has always been and continues to be to produce the highest quality, traditional goat's milk caramel sauces, using the freshest goat's milk available. Our dedicated team continues to produce our Goat's Milk Caramel Sauce right here on our kitchen, meticulously hand-stirring it to velvety perfection in small batches.

16 results
Cinnamon Caramel
From $ 7.00
Show options
Irish Whiskey Cream Caramel
From $ 7.00
Show options
Spicy Dark Chocolate Caramel
From $ 7.00
Show options
Cold Brew Coffee Caramel
From $ 7.00
Show options
Vermont Maple Caramel
From $ 7.00
Show options
Vanilla Bean Caramel
From $ 7.00
Show options
Salted Bourbon Caramel
From $ 7.00
Show options
The Original Caramel
From $ 7.00
Show options
Sweet Quartet Petit Caramel Sampler
$ 30.00
Show options
Sweet Duo Caramel Gift Box
$ 33.49
Show options
DIY Caramel Apple Kit
$ 19.99
in your cart
Drinking Chocolate Kit
$ 24.50
in your cart
Sweets Combo! Caramel And Taza Chocolate
$ 20.00
in your cart
Flight of Petit Caramels
$ 50.00
in your cart
Toads and Wild Woods
$ 28.00
in your cart
Toads and Bees
$ 28.00
in your cart