We make our mustard like we make our hot sauces; in small, seasonal random-as-all-heck flavors. Just like the hot sauce, we have some big batch flavors that are always available. Everything else is made 2-4 cases at a time and changes with the wind. So, if you like it, get it. If you don't, don't worry, we'll make something different next time.
The mustards come in 8 oz jars and are all made with organic Canadian yellow and brown mustard seed, organic white vinegar, salt plus whatever flavor is mentioned in the name and description. If you have any specific ingredient questions or concerns, just shoot us an email and ask!
We've added cases! Save 25% on a full case purchase. If you would like a mixed flavor case, specify which flavors in a note a checkout.
New! Want a mixed case, but don't know what you want? Choose the We-Pick case and we'll choose the flavors for you! You'll still save 25%.
Can't commit to a whole case, but still want a surprise? Order a TwoFer surprise pack and save!
The Big Boys:
Heady Topper - Heady Topper IPA really shines in this fabulous beer mustard.
Citizen Cider Smoked Onion - This is a lovely blend of Citizen Cider's Unified Press and maple wood smoked Vermont onions. Perfect on a turkey sandwich.
Vermont Jalapeno - A generous dose of Vermont green jalapenos kick this spicy mustard up to a whole new level.
Maple Sriracha - Eastman Long & Son's maple syrup, Vermont garlic scapes and Vermont jalapenos. This is excellent on sandwiches, burgers and fancy cheese.
Gustard - A Guster Mustard - We made this spicy pickle mustard in collaboration with the musical awesomeness that is Guster. This is a garlic, dill, jalapeno and cucumber mustard that is fabulous on sausage, burgers and pretzels. A portion of all proceeds are donated to Zeno Mountain Farm - one of the greatest places on earth.
The Random Flavors:
#1829 Honey Peppercorn - This is a sweet and zingy mustard that tastes great on sandwiches, in salad dressing and on pretzels.
Shipping is free for orders over $50! And $9.99 for all smaller orders.
You want your order approximately yesterday, right? Well, it's a good thing that we love getting your order out of our hands and into yours as fast as possible! That's why, if you order before our mail carrier comes by (usually between noon and 3), we usually get your order out the very same day.
Everything ships from our bakery in Montpelier, Vermont and generally orders going to individuals go out via USPS and wholesale orders go out either via FedEx or USPS depending on size (Please note: Larger web orders may still ship out via FedEx - please contact us if you would prefer your order to ship via a particular carrier - additional charges may apply). USPS orders will get to you in 1-3 days from pickup and FedEx boxes will arrive in 1-5 days. Here are the maps from USPS and FedEx with shipping times. Any questions? Shoot me an email at Claire@ButterflyBakeryVT.com and let me answer them.