We have 9 "big" flavors of hot sauce that are available year round and in stores. All other flavors are made in small ever changing 24-150 bottle batches on our stove. If you like a microbatch flavor, buy a lot, because it might never be made again. It's fun to keep you on your toes that way.
The hot sauces all come in those standard 5oz hot sauce bottles. As for ingredients, these are all vinegar based hot sauces with no gums or fillers. The ingredients (besides Vermont grown peppers, organic white vinegar and salt) are generally right there in the title. Send us a quick email if you need more specific details on a given flavor.
Are you wondering why a bakery is making hot sauce? Or who are the fine farmers who are growing the peppers that give our hot sauces their great flavors? Check out our Hot Sauce Story.
Save 25% on a full case purchase. If you would like a mixed flavor case, specify which flavors in a note a checkout. (Excluding Rum Barrel Fermented hot sauce). Do you want a mixed case, but don't know what you want? Choose the We-Pick case and we'll choose the flavors for you! You'll still save 25%.
Can't commit to a whole case, but still want a surprise? Order a TwoFer surprise pack and save!
The Big Craft Beer/Spirit Hot Sauce Flavors:
Heady Pepper - Made with the world famous Heady Topper IPA, this medium hot hot sauce is made with green jalapenos and will deliver you right up to hop sauce heaven. 🔥🔥🔥
Maple Rum Chipotle - Gosh, I love bringing folks favorites into the big leagues. This hot sauce is a warm hug of St Johnsbury Distillery's Maple Rum, Vermont jalapenos that we maple wood smoke ourselves, and a sweet splash of pure Vermont maple syrup. This makes for a great pizza and chili sauce.🔥🔥🔥
Vienna Beer Mustard - We make hot sauce. We make mustard. We love good beer. It took us surprisingly long to realize that we really ought to be making a beer mustard hot sauce. So we did. And it was good. On sausage. On pizza. On salad. And on burgers. This condiment of perfection is made with von Trapp Brewery Vienna Style Lager and Vermont serranos. 🔥🔥🔥
Habanero Lime Switchback - Switchback’s well balanced, smooth, signature ale rounds out the lively kick of Vermont grown habaneros and organic lime juice. This hot sauce with a burn is great on tacos, cocktails and seafood. Or, you know, everywhere... 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Peppercorn Porter - Peppercorn Porter attacks twice - first with the jalapenos and then with an uppercut of black pepper. But then it soothes you with the sumptuous malt from the lovely Yorkshire Porter from Queen City Brewery. This medium hot sauce is great on eggs, steaks and in a Bloody Mary. 🔥🔥🔥
The Big Non-Beer Hot Sauce Flavors:
Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha - Garlicky maple sweet heat. This is one of our most popular hot sauces and is made with some spectacular red jalapenos, organic garlic scapes and pure Vermont maple syrup. Also a 4-time Hot Pepper Award Winner! 🔥🔥🔥
Vermont Habs - Habaneros grown in Vermont's lush soil mean that our hot sauces deliver just as much flavor as heat. The subtle fruitiness of habaneros grown just for us isn't masked by sweeteners, gums and other stuff that you don't want. Vermont Habs is a fabulous habit. 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Smoked Onion - This started as a one off batch flavor. Then folks wanted another batch. And another. It was around the fourth "one off batch" that we realized that maple wood smoked onions and Vermont grown chili peppers makes for some fabulous hot sauce. 2-time Hot Pepper Award Winner and featured on Season 7 of Hot Ones! 🔥🔥🔥
Cilantro Onion - straight forward with mid-level heat this is our signature "use on anything and everything" hot sauce made with green jalapenos, robust cilantro and sweet Vermont onions.🔥🔥🔥
The Micro Batches:
#1810 Beans & Mags Magic Not So Hot Sauce - This is a magical sauce made with habanada peppers, which have all the flavor of habaneros but zero heat. Made for a ginger, a true, a bean, a mags, a dexter and a callie. This super mild sauce is great on eggs, pizza and beans. 🚫🔥
#1817 Rum Barrel Fermented Smoked Jalapeno - Start with some amazing True Love Farm Red Jalapenos. Then smoke them over maple wood. Then mash them, brine them and stuff them in a Dunc's Mill Rum barrel and ferment. Oh yes. Soooo good. This is our most coveted hot sauce and only available in limited runs. (Cannot be included in the discounted case). $10/bottle 🔥🔥🔥
#1826 Loafmore Lodge White Wine - Named for the Craig family camp at Joe's Pond. The Craige Family Happy Place for almost 100 years! This a bit-more-than- medium hot sauce is made with Shadow Creek Farm jalapenos and habaneros, and North Branch Winery Frontenac Gris white wine. It is excellent on pizza, roast veggies and cheeses. 🔥🔥🔥
#1844 Scape Sauce - This is not actually a hot sauce as it contains no heat or peppers. I make it just like I make the hot sauces, but with garlic scapes instead of peppers (scapes are the lovely green curly cues that grow above ground on a garlic plant). The vibrant garlic flavor of the part of the garlic plant that farmers usually turn back into the soil makes for a thick and versatile sauce. 🚫🔥
#1845 Vermont Paprika - The Boldog Hungarian pepper is traditionally used to make sweet paprika and we blended it with a spicier Fresno chili to make a less hot, super versitile sauce. It is excellent on pizza, burritos and party dips. 🔥🔥
#1902 Elderflower Ghost - First you get an amazingly delicate flowery flavor of both St Johnsbury Distillery’s Elderflower Rum and ghost peppers, then you get smacked in the face with the heat of the peppers. Our most popular ghost hot sauce tastes great on turkey sandwiches and fancy cheeses.🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
#1903 Smoked Jalapeno Ginger - This vibrant flavor bomb of a sauce is deeply smoky and brightly gingery. It will bring oomph to bland dishes and bring flavorful foods to new levels. It is yummy on beans, roast veggies and stinky cheeses.🔥🔥🔥
#1910 Fermented Ghost - This kick you in the kisser hot sauce starts with the delicate flowery flavor of ghost peppers, then you get the rich umami of the ferment, then you get the full punch of all that Vermont ghosts have to offer. It is yummy with beans, beef and ramen.🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
#1911 Fermented Sriracha - Fresno peppers are little pops of heat and bright flavor. We fermented them with Vermont garlic scapes then cooked it all up with pure Vermont maple syrup. It is great on pizza, salad and cheeses.🔥🔥🔥
#1921 Szechuan Peppercorn - The Szechuan and black pepper combined with Dutchess Farms green jalapenos gives this hot sauce a bright, citrusy one-two punch of flavor. This sauce goes great with fish, rice and mushrooms.🔥🔥🔥
#1925 Mix o' Peppers - We brine fermented a some Dutchess Farm green jalapenos for a couple months, then blended them up with pablanos and habaneros to make this surprisingly complex, multi-layered hot sauce. It tastes particularly good on rice, burritos and chicken. 🔥🔥🔥🔥
The Exception to the Rule
We make special, exclusive batches of hot sauce for The Alchemist (maker of Heady Topper - one of the world's best IPA's). This used to be only available at The Alchemist's shop, but they are now letting us hold back a limited number of cases for sale on our website. These are only available until they run out and then won't be back until the next batch that we make for The Alchemist (usually every 1-2 months). 🔥🔥🔥
Red Heady - (AKA Heady Pepper Owner's Reserve) This is a hot sauce that we make specially for The Alchemist. We’ve crafted a custom blend of Vermont jalapenos and habaneros which mix beautifully with Heady Topper’s bright hoppiness and together deliver you right up to hop sauce heaven. 🔥🔥🔥
Did you know that we're a FuegoBox All-Star? We've done custom hot sauces for Fuego's subscription box that you can't get anywhere else - even here! Check them out at https://www.fuegobox.com
Both our Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha and our Maple Wood Smoked Onion each won two Hot Pepper Awards and our whole company won the Hybrid Award for Innovation! We're especially proud of that last one because innovation is part of our ethos and it's pretty cool to see someone else recognize that!
See a video of when The Alchemist's owner John Kimmich came out to our old location make some Heady Pepper Owners Reserve.
Shipping is free for orders over $50! And $9.99 for all smaller orders.
You want your order approximately yesterday, right? Well, it's a good thing that we love getting your order out of our hands and into yours as fast as possible! That's why, if you order before our mail carrier comes by (usually between noon and 3), we usually get your order out the very same day.
Everything ships from our bakery in Montpelier, Vermont and generally orders going to individuals go out via USPS and wholesale orders go out either via FedEx or USPS depending on size (Please note: Larger web orders may still ship out via FedEx - please contact us if you would prefer your order to ship via a particular carrier - additional charges may apply). USPS orders will get to you in 1-3 days from pickup and FedEx boxes will arrive in 1-5 days. Here are the maps from USPS and FedEx with shipping times. Any questions? Shoot me an email at Claire@ButterflyBakeryVT.com and let me answer them.