Award Winning Products

From our granolas to our whole seed mustards to our goat's milk caramel sauces, Butterfly Bakery of Vermont and Fat Toad Caramel are no strangers to being recognized for crafting some of the best of the best. All of the products here are award winners! 

13 results
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Maple Wood Smoked Onion Hot Sauce
Maple Wood Smoked Onion Hot Sauce
From $ 5.00
Show options
Mighty Tasty Granola - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Mighty Tasty Granola
From $ 5.00
Show options
Fat Toad Farm Original Caramel Sauce
The Original Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Rum Barrel Fermented Smoked Jalapeno Hot Sauce
Rum Barrel Fermented Smoked Jalapeno Hot Sauce
$ 14.00
in your cart
Jar of Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Hard Cider Smoked Onion Mustard with a gold metal badge sitting on a wood surface with 2 cans of hard cider, an onion and 2 apples
Sold Out
Hard Cider Smoked Onion Mustard
$ 9.00
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Taco Vibes Only Hot Sauce
Taco Vibes Only Hot Sauce
From $ 7.00
Show options
Fat Toad Farm Salted Bourbon Caramel Sauce
Salted Bourbon Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Bottle of Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Hot House hot sauce with a 'As Seen on Hot Ones' badge sitting on a table alongside a burrito cut in half on a plate
Hot House Hot Sauce
From $ 5.00
Show options
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha
Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha Hot Sauce
From $ 5.00
Show options
Gustard - A Guster Mustard - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Gustard - A Guster Mustard
$ 9.00
in your cart
Fat Toad Farm Vanilla Caramel Sauce
Vanilla Bean Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Fat Toad Farm Cinnamon Caramel Sauce
Cinnamon Caramel
From $ 7.59
Show options
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Mellow Vibes Only Hot Sauce
Mellow Vibes Only Hot Sauce
$ 9.00
in your cart